Jon Ingham
  • Home
  • Consulting
    • Technology analyst
  • Training
  • Writing
    • The Social Organization
    • Better HR departments
    • Innovating Reward
    • Strategic Human Capital Management
  • Speaking
    • Chairing and facilitating
  • Advice
  • Contact

HR in competitive positioning and why we’re not strategic!

29/7/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
Porter offers a couple of useful tools to develop competitive positioning – e.g the value chain which is pictured here for a traditional, manufacturing type of business (you know this one as well, right?)

Basically this value chain suggests that businesses  buy things in, transform them in some way, send them out and deliver a bit of services for customers.  All sectors and each organisation, to a greater or lesser degree, have their own value chains.  You should know what yours looks like!

All of these activities, the primary activities of the business, are how the business develops its margin and profitability, the key need being to align them around its differentiation or cost leadership position.  This is how it develops and retains its competitive advantage.

But there are also a couple of secondary, or support, activities which don’t play a direct role in creating margin or competitive advantage, but support the primary activities to do this.

And, as you’ll know or will have noticed, one of these is HR.  i.e in a business competing via competitive positioning, HR is a support function – by definition.  So a lot of the stuff which is discussed in HR conferences and publications is just gumph because HR can’t be strategic in this model.

I think a lot of what we’re really talking about when we use the word strategic is just being proactive,  i.e we can either be proactive – at the metaphorical table when the big business issues are discussed, so that we can immediately start working on doing what we need to do in HR to support the business.  Or, we can be reactive – staying behind our locked rooms at the end of the long corridor in the basement until the FD remembers to tell us what was decided three months ago.  Being proactive is obviously a good thing, but it’s not the same as being strategic.  And in the example I’ve given here, the focus of the business is all about the business = nobody wants any neat ideas from HR thank you very much, because it’s not one of the primary activities.

So it’s a big disadvantage for a business trying to use competitive positioning that they can’t use the potential benefits of competing on people, via HR.  And it’s means that HR becomes a bit of a back water because we are, by definition, a support function.

The good news is that the alternative forms of business strategy are increasingly becoming more popular and these offer greater opportunities to contribute strategically to the business, and therefore to make working in HR a more valued activity too…
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    My Strategic HCM Blog

    Categories

    All
    Blog
    Changes In The Workforce
    HR And Competitive Positioning

    Author

    Advice from Jon Ingham, strategic HR consultant.

    Archives

    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    September 2018
    November 2017
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014

    RSS Feed

Consulting
Training
Writing
Speaking 
Advice
Contact

 © 2020 Jon Ingham. All Rights Reserved
jon@joningham.com  |  +44 7904 185134
The Social Organization​
Strategic Dynamics ; Strategic HCM
HCM Blog